HR Software Comparison
Gusto vs Shiftie
Comprehensive comparison of features, pricing plans, pros & cons, and overall verdict to help you choose the best tool for your business.
⚡ Quick Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Choose Gusto if:
- You need starting prices from $0/mo.
- Key Advantage: Commission: Earn a $100 bonus for your first customer.
Choose Shiftie if:
- Your budget aligns with $0/mo.
- Key Advantage: Commission: 25% for Referral Links - TSG.
Gusto
★ 4.5 (10 reviews)
Trusted by more than 500,000 businesses and their teams. Gusto's people platform helps growing businesses onboard, pay, insure, and support their hardworking teams with payroll, benefits, and more.
Starting Price $0/mo
Visit Gusto Website →
Shiftie
★ 4.5 (10 reviews)
Staff scheduling made simple. Shiftie is a smart staff scheduling tool that simplifies rota planning, tracks availability, and improves team communication, saving time and ensuring you're always staffed when it counts.
Starting Price $0/mo
Visit Shiftie Website →
Feature & Capability Comparison
| Features | Gusto $0/mo | Shiftie $0/mo |
|---|---|---|
| Read Review | Read Review |
Pros & Cons Breakdown
Gusto Pros & Cons
Advantages
- ✓ Commission: Earn a $100 bonus for your first customer
- ✓ Commission: Earn $700 for your third successful referral to run payroll (Expired March 1st).
- ✓ Commission: Earn $1,000 for your fifth successful referral to payroll run
- ✓ Commission: Earn $500 for your first successful referral to run payroll (Expired March 1st).
- ✓ Commission: Earn $600 for your second successful referral to run payroll (Expired March 1st).
- ✓ Commission: Earn $900 for your fourth successful referral to run payroll (Expired March 1st).
- ✓ Commission: Earn $1,200 for your fifth or subsequent successful referral who runs payroll (Expired March 1st).
- ✓ Commission: Earn $500 for your third successful referral to payroll run
- ✓ Commission: Earn $300 for your first successful referral to run payroll
- ✓ Commission: Earn $400 for your second successful referral to payroll run
- ✓ Commission: Earn $700 for your fourth successful referral to payroll run
- ✓ Commission: Earn $300 for every new customer (who runs payroll) you refer to Gusto & get a limited-time $200 bonus. Bonus ends March 1st, 2026.
- ✓ Commission: Earn $300 for every new customer (who runs payroll) you refer to Gusto.
- ✓ Categories: HR Software, Governance, Risk, & Compliance, B2B Marketplaces
Shiftie Pros & Cons
Advantages
- ✓ Commission: 25% for Referral Links - TSG
- ✓ Commission: 25% for Lead Submission - TSG
- ✓ Commission: 20% for Referral Links - Referral Partners
- ✓ Commission: 35% for Resellers First Year - TSG
- ✓ Commission: 20% for Lead Submission - Referral Partners
- ✓ Commission: 30% for Deals First Year - Resellers
- ✓ Commission: 10% for Deals Lifetime - TSG
- ✓ Commission: 10% for Deals Lifetime - Resellers
- ✓ Commission: 20% for Referral Links - Integration Partners
- ✓ Commission: 20% for Lead Submission - Integration Partners
- ✓ Commission: 30% for Deals First Year - Integration Partners
- ✓ Commission: 10% for Deals Lifetime - Integration Partners
- ✓ Commission: 20% for Referral Links - Referral & Reseller Partners
- ✓ Commission: 20% for Lead Submission - Referral & Reseller Partners
- ✓ Commission: 30% for Deals First Year - Resellers & Referral Group
- ✓ Commission: 10% for Deals Lifetime - Resellers & Referrals
- ✓ Categories: HR Software
Frequently Asked Questions
❓ Which is cheaper, Gusto or Shiftie?
Gusto is generally more affordable, starting at $0/month compared to $0/month.
❓ Does Gusto or Shiftie offer a free trial?
Gusto does not explicitly list a free trial. Shiftie does not explicitly list a free trial.
❓ Which tool has a higher user rating between Gusto and Shiftie?
Gusto holds a higher average rating of 0/5 stars.